Metal Clad vs Metal Enclosed Switchgear

Metal Clad vs Metal Enclosed Switchgear

Choosing the right switchgear is critical for safety, reliability, and cost-efficiency. Here's a quick breakdown of metal clad and metal enclosed switchgear to help you decide:

  • Metal Clad Switchgear: Ideal for medium-voltage (2.4 kV to 38 kV) systems. Offers separate compartments for components, advanced safety features, and easier maintenance. Best for high-risk environments like industrial plants or data centers.
  • Metal Enclosed Switchgear: Designed for low-voltage (up to 1 kV) systems. Features a single enclosure, compact size, and lower upfront costs. Suitable for commercial buildings or smaller facilities with lower safety demands.

Quick Comparison

Feature Metal Clad Switchgear Metal Enclosed Switchgear
Voltage Range 2.4 kV to 38 kV (medium) Up to 1 kV (low)
Enclosure Design Separate compartments Single enclosure
Safety High (grounded barriers) Basic (no internal barriers)
Maintenance Targeted (no full shutdown) Full system shutdown required
Space Required Larger footprint Compact design
Cost Higher upfront cost Lower upfront cost

Bottom Line: Choose metal clad for safety and reliability in critical applications. Opt for metal enclosed for cost-effective, space-saving solutions in low-risk setups.

What is the Difference Between Metal-Clad & Metal-Enclosed Switchgear?

Metal Clad Switchgear Overview

Metal clad switchgear (MCS) is a high-performance solution tailored for medium-voltage applications, typically handling voltages between 2.4 kV and 38 kV. It plays a vital role in power distribution systems where safety, reliability, and uninterrupted operation are non-negotiable. Designed to last 20–30 years or more, this equipment ensures long-term dependability for critical infrastructures.

"Metal-clad switchgear is typically considered top-of-the-line equipment, offering the most safety features, higher current interrupting, and more voltage options." – Eric Gersh, General Manager, Southwest Electric

The standout feature of metal clad switchgear is its fully compartmentalized design. Circuit breakers, busbars, and control gear are housed in separate, grounded enclosures. This setup creates multiple physical barriers, minimizing the risk of accidental contact and containing arc faults to specific sections, which enhances both safety and operational reliability.

Main Features

The robust metal-clad construction shields the equipment from internal electrical faults and external hazards like dust, moisture, and physical damage. This durability makes it an excellent choice for harsh industrial environments.

Its modular design provides flexibility, allowing facilities to expand their electrical systems as power requirements increase. The withdrawable circuit breaker design enables quick replacements, ensuring minimal downtime during maintenance.

To further protect both equipment and personnel, advanced protective systems are integrated, including protective relays, current transformers (CTs), and voltage transformers (VTs). These systems automatically detect and respond to abnormal conditions.

Metal clad switchgear adheres to rigorous industry standards, such as IEC 62271-200 and ANSI/IEEE C37.20.2, boasting an internal arc classification of AFLR and a partition class of PM. It is engineered to perform up to 10,000 operations while maintaining consistent safety and reliability.

For added safety, remote circuit breaker racking options allow operators to manage the equipment from a secure distance, reducing exposure to potential hazards.

Pros

Metal clad switchgear stands out for its superior safety and reliability. The compartmentalized design not only isolates faults, preventing them from escalating, but also simplifies troubleshooting. These features make it a trusted choice for critical applications in sectors like healthcare, data centers, and industrial facilities.

With its robust design and advanced safety features, metal clad switchgear sets a high benchmark, paving the way for a comparison with metal enclosed designs.

Metal Enclosed Switchgear Overview

Metal enclosed switchgear stands apart from metal clad systems by prioritizing simplicity and affordability, particularly for low-voltage applications. It’s a popular choice in U.S. facilities where dependable power distribution is necessary, but the heightened safety measures of metal clad systems aren’t required.

The hallmark of metal enclosed switchgear is its integrated design. Unlike metal clad systems, which isolate each component within separate compartments, this type of switchgear houses all components within a single enclosure. This streamlined design is especially suited for low-voltage setups handling up to 1 kV. This distinction lays the groundwork for understanding its specific features and applications.

In the United States, metal enclosed switchgear is widely used across industries, particularly in commercial and industrial facilities. It’s typically installed where incoming electrical service exceeds 480/600V, serving as a bridge between basic distribution panels and high-voltage transmission systems. The equipment’s sheet metal construction ensures full enclosure, with only essential ventilation openings and inspection windows for operational monitoring. This design strikes a balance between protection and accessibility, making routine maintenance straightforward.

Main Features

The integrated design of metal enclosed switchgear brings several advantages. For starters, its layout simplifies maintenance by providing easy access to all components, which helps cut down on both service time and costs over the equipment’s lifespan.

Another key benefit is its compact size. Because it occupies less floor space compared to systems with compartmentalized designs, it’s an ideal solution for facilities where electrical room space is at a premium. This makes it especially useful in urban commercial buildings and retrofit projects.

The equipment can be tailored to specific needs, accommodating components like fixed-mounted power breakers, bare bus connections, instrument transformers, and specialized accessories. Custom configurations are also available for more complex applications, such as automatic source-transfer systems, split-bus sections, or ring-bus setups.

Pros and Cons

Metal enclosed switchgear offers clear economic benefits for many commercial and industrial applications. Its lower upfront cost is largely due to its simpler construction and easier installation compared to compartmentalized systems. Maintenance costs are also kept in check, as this equipment doesn’t require the intricate adjustments, programming, or dielectric testing that more advanced systems demand.

The space-saving design is another major advantage. By requiring less room, facilities can optimize their electrical spaces, potentially adding more equipment or reducing the overall building footprint - an important consideration for retrofit projects with limited room for expansion.

However, this unified design comes with some trade-offs. One notable drawback is its lower arc-fault protection. Unlike higher-grade systems, metal enclosed switchgear lacks arc-resistant enclosures and arc-extinguishing devices, which could pose safety concerns. Additionally, it offers less protection against environmental factors like corrosion, dust, moisture, and vermin, making it more vulnerable in harsh conditions.

sbb-itb-501186b

Main Differences Between Metal Clad and Metal Enclosed Switchgear

When choosing between metal-clad and metal-enclosed switchgear, understanding their core differences is crucial for facility managers and electrical engineers. While both play vital roles in power distribution, their designs and functionalities cater to different needs.

One key distinction lies in how they handle compartmentalization. Metal-clad switchgear separates its components - like circuit breakers and busbars - into individual enclosures, ensuring each part operates in its own protected space. On the other hand, metal-enclosed switchgear houses all components within a single shared enclosure.

This difference directly impacts safety. Metal-clad systems use grounded metal barriers to fully isolate primary circuit components, enhancing protection. In contrast, metal-enclosed systems offer minimal or no internal barriers. Moreover, their voltage ranges differ: metal-clad switchgear supports medium-voltage applications (2.4 kV to 38 kV), while metal-enclosed switchgear is designed for low-voltage setups (up to 1 kV).

Comparison Table

Feature Metal-Clad Switchgear Metal-Enclosed Switchgear
Enclosure Design Separate compartments for each component Single enclosure for all components
Voltage Range Medium-voltage (2.4 kV to 38 kV) Low-voltage (up to 1 kV)
Circuit Breaker Type Draw-out type Fixed-mounted
Safety Features Grounded barriers, automatic shutters Basic enclosure protection
Operational Life Up to 10,000 operations Less than 1,000 operations
Space Requirements Larger footprint Compact design
Maintenance Access Targeted maintenance possible Requires full system shutdown
Bus Configuration Insulated primary bus conductors May use bare bus connections
Fault Current Handling Handles higher fault currents Designed for lower fault currents

Metal-clad switchgear’s compartmentalized design allows for targeted maintenance, meaning individual components can be serviced without shutting down the entire system. By contrast, metal-enclosed switchgear, with its fixed configuration, often requires a complete system shutdown for maintenance. Space is another consideration: metal-clad systems need more room due to their separate compartments, while metal-enclosed systems are more compact, making them a practical choice for facilities with limited space.

Lastly, fault current handling sets these systems apart. Metal-clad switchgear is built for environments with higher fault currents and more demanding conditions. Meanwhile, metal-enclosed switchgear is better suited for smaller load capacities and lower fault current applications.

Application Factors in the United States

In the U.S., electrical installations must comply with strict regulations and market conditions that directly impact project outcomes. Understanding these requirements helps electrical professionals make choices that align with both safety standards and cost considerations.

Standards and Technical Requirements

Metal-clad switchgear in the United States was initially defined under ANSI C37.20.2-1987, but the current standard is IEEE C37.20.2-2022. This standard outlines critical features like draw-out switching devices, automatic shutters, and fully insulated primary bus conductors. On the other hand, metal-enclosed switchgear is governed by ANSI C37.20.3-1987, which includes configurations with protective relays, power fuses, bare bus connections, instrumentation transformers, and control accessories. For applications involving metal-enclosed low-voltage power circuit breaker switchgear, IEEE C37.20.1 provides additional guidelines. To ensure reliability and safety, both types of switchgear must also meet NEMA conformance testing standards.

Voltage classifications play a significant role in determining the right equipment. Metal-clad systems are typically used in medium-voltage applications (2.4 kV to 38 kV), making them ideal for industrial plants and utility substations. Meanwhile, metal-enclosed switchgear is designed for low-voltage applications (up to 1 kV), commonly found in commercial buildings and smaller industrial facilities.

Safety considerations are another major factor. Metal-clad systems offer enhanced safety due to their compartmentalized design, which separates low-voltage compartments and isolates the main bus. In contrast, metal-enclosed switchgear requires heightened safety measures because any section may contain an energized main bus.

Platforms like Electrical Trader simplify the process of sourcing switchgear that meets these standards, ensuring compliance and efficiency.

Finding Equipment on Electrical Trader

Electrical Trader

With these technical and safety demands in mind, Electrical Trader offers an efficient way to procure compliant switchgear. Its online marketplace centralizes the sourcing of both new and used metal-clad and metal-enclosed switchgear from a variety of manufacturers and suppliers.

For many projects, used and refurbished equipment provides a practical solution. Certified refurbished medium-voltage switchgear often comes with warranties, offering a cost-effective option without sacrificing reliability. Proper maintenance significantly extends the lifespan of switchgear, with well-maintained systems lasting over 35 years, compared to just 17 years for neglected equipment.

Electrical Trader’s platform enables professionals to compare options based on manufacturers, voltage ratings, and price points. With access to real-time pricing and availability, electrical contractors can refine their bidding strategies and deliver more accurate project estimates. This streamlined approach supports the growing demand for specialized safety-compliant equipment.

Conclusion

Deciding between metal-clad and metal-enclosed switchgear comes down to understanding your specific needs for voltage, safety, cost, and operational requirements. Metal-clad switchgear is best suited for medium-voltage applications (2.4 kV to 38 kV), offering a compartmentalized design rated for up to 10,000 operations. On the other hand, metal-enclosed switchgear is tailored to low-voltage applications (up to 1 kV), featuring a single enclosure design rated for less than 1,000 operations.

Metal-clad systems stand out for their enhanced safety features, with separate enclosures for components that allow targeted maintenance without shutting down the entire system. In contrast, metal-enclosed systems are valued for their compact design, lower upfront cost, and simplified access for routine maintenance. These differences make metal-clad systems ideal for high-risk, medium-voltage scenarios where uptime is critical, while metal-enclosed systems are a practical choice for low-risk, cost-sensitive installations like commercial buildings or smaller industrial facilities.

As outlined by IEC standards, the structural and design differences between these two types of switchgear significantly influence their performance and suitability. Whether you prioritize the advanced protection of metal-clad systems or the budget-friendly, space-saving design of metal-enclosed switchgear, the goal is to select equipment that aligns with your operational demands and regulatory needs.

To simplify the selection process, Electrical Trader provides access to both new and refurbished switchgear, all compliant with industry standards. With real-time pricing and availability, contractors can compare options and make informed choices that meet both technical specifications and budget constraints.

FAQs

What safety features make metal clad switchgear better suited for high-risk environments compared to metal enclosed switchgear?

Metal clad switchgear stands out for its safety-focused design, making it a great fit for high-risk environments. It features separate, grounded compartments for individual components, which help contain faults and stop them from escalating. On top of that, its arc-resistant construction reduces the chances of arc flashes, offering an added layer of protection for both workers and equipment.

These characteristics make metal clad switchgear a dependable option for challenging or hazardous settings where safety and long-term reliability are top priorities.

What are the differences in maintenance requirements between metal-clad and metal-enclosed switchgear, and how do they affect downtime?

Metal-clad switchgear often demands more detailed maintenance because of its compartmentalized structure and advanced safety mechanisms. While these features enhance protection, they can lead to extended maintenance times and, in turn, increased operational downtime.

In contrast, metal-enclosed switchgear is built with easier access to its components, streamlining maintenance and cutting down repair times. This design makes it a practical option for environments where keeping downtime to a minimum is a top priority.

When is metal enclosed switchgear a better choice than metal clad switchgear?

Metal enclosed switchgear is a smart choice when space is tight, budget constraints are important, and safety requirements are less demanding. It's especially well-suited for low-voltage systems or situations where the advanced safety features of metal clad switchgear aren't required.

This type of switchgear works particularly well in indoor spaces with limited room or projects where a compact design and easy accessibility are key. Its smaller size and cost-effective nature make it a reliable option for many standard power distribution setups.

Related posts

 

Back to blog